active

5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI 49651

$469,900

$361 per ft²

4 Bed

2 Bath

1,300 Sq Ft

10.0 Acres

Listing Office: City2Shore Real Estate Northern Michigan

Custom-built wooden home in northern Michigan, featuring a rustic design, large front porch, and surrounded by lush greenery on 10 acres, ideal for outdoor living and relaxation.

Cozy covered porch with stone fireplace, wooden ceiling, and seating area overlooking serene northern Michigan landscape.

Covered porch with stone fireplace, wooden ceiling beams, and seating area surrounded by northern Michigan forest, showcasing outdoor living space of custom-built home on 10 acres.

Mudroom with custom wood cabinetry, red shiplap walls, and large window showcasing northern Michigan countryside, featuring stacked washer and dryer, and wooden bench for storage.

Custom-built home interior hallway featuring red and gray walls, wooden accents, a staircase, and a closed door, reflecting the craftsmanship and cozy atmosphere of the property at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Custom kitchen with rustic wooden cabinets, stainless steel appliances, large windows showcasing northern Michigan nature, and a farmhouse sink, highlighting craftsmanship and open-concept design in a 4-bedroom home.

Custom kitchen with rustic oak cabinets, stainless steel appliances, and granite countertops, showcasing a warm and inviting design in a 4-bedroom home on 10 acres in Lake City, MI.

Custom kitchen featuring oak cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and a teal towel hanging from the stove, showcasing the warm, rustic design of the home at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Custom-built kitchen with rustic wood cabinetry, large windows showcasing northern Michigan countryside, dining table, and modern appliances.

Custom-built kitchen with wooden cabinets, granite countertops, large windows showcasing northern Michigan countryside views, and modern appliances.

Open-concept kitchen with wooden cabinets, farmhouse sink, and large windows showcasing serene views of northern Michigan greenery.

Kitchen interior with large windows showcasing serene northern Michigan countryside views, custom cabinetry, granite countertops, and farmhouse sink, highlighting the craftsmanship of the home at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Custom-built kitchen featuring rustic wood finishes, large windows with scenic views, a farmhouse sink, and a dining table, highlighting craftsmanship in a northern Michigan home.

Custom-built kitchen and dining area with wooden cabinetry, large windows offering natural light, and rustic decor, showcasing the craftsmanship of the 4-bedroom home on 10 acres in Lake City, MI.

Cozy dining area with rustic wood paneling, a black woodstove, and a wooden table surrounded by X-back chairs, featuring decorative wall art and natural light from the window, reflecting the custom craftsmanship of the Lake City, MI home.

Rustic dining area featuring a wooden table with a white runner, surrounded by chairs and a vase of flowers, against a backdrop of wood-paneled walls, reflecting the custom craftsmanship of the Lake City, MI home.

Cozy interior view of custom-built home featuring a woodstove, natural wood walls, and large window overlooking the northern Michigan countryside, highlighting craftsmanship and warmth.

Cozy living room with custom wood finishes, large windows showcasing nature, leather sectional sofa, woodstove, and rustic decor in a northern Michigan home.

Cozy living room featuring a large sectional sofa, rustic wood accents, and a modern electric fireplace, with large windows showcasing views of the northern Michigan countryside.

Cozy living room with custom wood finishes, large windows offering natural light, and a comfortable sectional sofa, showcasing the craftsmanship of the 4-bedroom, 2-bath home in Lake City, MI.

Cozy living area featuring a leather sectional sofa with decorative pillows, a round woven coffee table, and large windows showcasing the serene northern Michigan landscape.

Cozy woodstove in a custom-built home with warm wooden walls, complementing the northern Michigan countryside ambiance.

Cozy interior of a custom-built home featuring rustic wooden beams, handcrafted cabinetry, and an open-concept layout, showcasing a dining area and staircase, with large windows offering views of the surrounding nature.

Cozy bedroom featuring a metal bed frame, gray walls, wooden ceiling beams, and natural light from a window, showcasing the custom craftsmanship of the home at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Cozy bedroom featuring a metal bed frame with decorative pillows and textured bedding, showcasing rustic wood accents and a serene atmosphere, reflecting the custom craftsmanship of the Lake City, MI home.

Custom bathroom featuring green cabinetry, granite countertop, and a walk-in shower with natural stone tiles, showcasing rustic wood accents and modern fixtures in a northern Michigan home.

Custom bathroom interior featuring wood and stone accents, glass shower enclosure, green cabinetry, and natural light from window.

Custom bathroom sink with granite countertop, dark faucet, decorative plants, and storage jars, showcasing rustic charm in a northern Michigan home.

Custom shower with glass enclosure, stone tile walls, wooden accents, and modern fixtures in a northern Michigan home bathroom.

Showerhead in a custom bathroom featuring slate tile, showcasing modern design and craftsmanship in the 4-bedroom home at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Custom wood interior hallway featuring a horse painting, handcrafted wooden doors, and rustic rough-sawn walls, reflecting the craftsmanship of the 4-bedroom, 2-bath home in Lake City, MI.

Cozy bedroom with wooden walls and ceiling, featuring a white metal bed, decorative pillows, and a small side table, showcasing natural light from the window and highlighting custom craftsmanship in a northern Michigan home.

Cozy bedroom featuring custom rough-sawn wood walls and ceiling, large window with views of nature, white metal bed frame, and a comfortable seating area with a gray chair and side table.

Cozy bedroom with rustic wood paneling, handcrafted furniture, and natural light highlighting the custom craftsmanship, located in a 4-bedroom home on 10 acres in Lake City, MI.

Cozy reading nook with a gray armchair, wooden side table, and decorative lamp against a backdrop of natural wood paneling in a custom-built home.

Wooden hallway with custom craftsmanship, featuring handmade doors, rough-sawn wood walls, and a cozy chair beside a small table, emphasizing the rustic charm of the 4-bedroom, 2-bath home in Lake City, MI.

Cozy bedroom featuring a white metal bed with blue and striped bedding, wooden walls, and large windows, highlighting custom craftsmanship and rustic charm in a northern Michigan home.

Cozy bedroom featuring a custom wood ceiling, natural wood paneling, a striped bedspread, and large windows offering views of northern Michigan's countryside.

Cozy bedroom featuring a custom-built bunk bed with a lower full-size mattress, navy bedding, wooden accents, and a warm wood floor, showcasing northern Michigan craftsmanship and design.

Bathroom featuring custom craftsmanship with wooden walls, dark cabinetry, modern fixtures, and a tiled shower, showcasing a blend of rustic and contemporary design elements.

Cozy reading nook with a patterned chair and a wicker basket, featuring warm wooden flooring and sloped ceiling in a custom-built home in northern Michigan.

Custom-built home at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI, featuring wooden exterior, red roof, and garage, set on 10 acres of northern Michigan countryside.

Custom-built wooden home with red accents surrounded by northern Michigan greenery, showcasing craftsmanship and serene countryside setting near Lake City.

Custom-built 4-bedroom home in northern Michigan, featuring a rustic wooden exterior, covered porch, and stone fireplace, surrounded by lush greenery on 10 acres of countryside.

Custom-built home with wooden exterior, red roof, stone fireplace, and covered porch, surrounded by greenery on 10 acres in Lake City, MI.

Covered porch of a custom-built home in northern Michigan featuring wicker and metal chairs, a stone fireplace, and views of surrounding nature on a 10-acre property.

Cozy stone fireplace with wooden mantel, surrounded by rustic wood paneling and stacked firewood, enhancing the inviting atmosphere of the custom-built home in northern Michigan.

Covered porch with stone fireplace, wicker chair, and outdoor seating, surrounded by lush northern Michigan woods, showcasing peaceful countryside living at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Open field with trees and lush greenery, showcasing the serene northern Michigan countryside surrounding the 4-bedroom, 2-bath home for sale at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI.

Scenic view of open field bordered by trees, showcasing the natural beauty of the 10-acre property at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI, ideal for outdoor activities and relaxation.

Covered porch of a custom-built home overlooking lush northern Michigan woods, showcasing a serene outdoor space ideal for relaxation and wildlife observation.

Custom-built home exterior featuring natural wood siding and red trim, showcasing large windows and a welcoming front door, set on a picturesque 10-acre property in Lake City, MI.

Custom-built home exterior featuring wooden shingles, a red roof, and a large window in the gable, showcasing northern Michigan craftsmanship.

Lush northern Michigan landscape with trees and ferns, featuring a fire pit, highlighting the serene outdoor setting of the property at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City.

Custom-built cabin exterior with wooden siding, stone feature, and "Cabin" sign, surrounded by northern Michigan greenery, reflecting serene countryside living.

Cabin sign featuring the word "CABIN" with Michigan silhouette, established 2023, mounted on wooden wall, reflecting northern Michigan's rustic charm.

Aerial view of a custom-built home with a red roof surrounded by lush greenery on 10 acres in Lake City, MI, showcasing northern Michigan countryside and natural beauty.

Aerial view of a custom-built 4-bedroom, 2-bath home on 10 acres in Lake City, MI, surrounded by trees and featuring a red roof, showcasing the serene northern Michigan countryside.

Aerial view of a custom-built 4-bedroom home on 10 acres in northern Michigan, surrounded by lush greenery and farmland, showcasing the peaceful countryside and natural beauty.

Gravel driveway leading through lush greenery and trees at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI, showcasing the serene northern Michigan countryside.

Fire pit surrounded by lush greenery and ferns, with a backdrop of dense trees in northern Michigan countryside, highlighting outdoor living space on 10 acres near custom-built home.

Aerial view of a 10-acre wooded property in Lake City, Michigan, featuring a red-roofed home, surrounded by lush greenery and open fields, highlighting the serene countryside setting ideal for outdoor activities.

Map highlighting the property location at 5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI, surrounded by wooded areas and nearby roads, emphasizing its connection to local outdoor activities and real estate opportunities.

Custom-built 4-bedroom, 2-bath home with wooden exterior, covered porch, and large windows, set on 10 acres in northern Michigan countryside.

This stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath custom-built home sits on 10 acres of peaceful northern Michigan countryside, just a quarter mile from the riding trails. Every inch of this home was thoughtfully crafted, from the handmade doors and cabinets to the custom rough-sawn wood floors and walls that bring warmth, character and beauty to every room. The open-concept kitchen, dining and living area features large windows that fill the space with natural light and offer serene views of the surrounding nature. The main floor hosts one bedroom, while the upstairs has three additional bedrooms and a second custom bathroom with a tiled shower. And don't miss out on checking out the "secret" hideway/reading nook upstairs! A woodstove adds an extra touch of cozy comfort on chilly evenings, while the spacious mudroom off the two-stall garage includes convenient main-floor laundry facilities. Step outside onto the covered porch where an outdoor fireplace creates the perfect gathering spot to unwind and enjoy the sights and sounds of wildlife. Located just five miles from the Manistee River and twelve miles from Lake Missaukee, this property offers the perfect blend of seclusion and accessibility for relaxing and fun. With thousands of acres of state land nearby, opportunities for deer and bird hunting, fishing, morel and trail riding are endless. Currently operating as a successful short-term rental, this property is ready for you to step right in and continue its success or make it your own. Whether you’re looking for an income-producing investment, a comfortable year-round residence, an up-north getaway, or a perfect combination of all three, this home offers endless possibilities. Thoughtfully maintained and designed for both comfort and style, it’s a place where relaxation meets opportunity—ready for its next chapter with you! This is Northern Michigan living at its finest-custom craftmanship, natural beauty and outdoor adventure all in one extraordinary property.

Listing Agent: Sue Whipple

License Number:

Offered by: City2Shore Real Estate Northern Michigan

Office Phone: 231-839-0077

MLS: #1940099

Northern Great Lakes Realtors MLS

Date Added: 10/31/2025 04:06:42 am

Last Update: 12/02/2025 08:18:30 pm

Days on Market: 33

Interior

General: Granite Counters, Mud Room, DSL
Appliances: Refrigerator, Oven/Range, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer
Laundry: Main Level
Basement: Crawl Space
Flooring: Wood
Heating: true, Forced Air, Fireplace(s), Propane, Wood
Fireplace: Wood Burning, Stove, Fireplace
Disability Feature: None

Exterior

General: None
Parking: Gravel, Attached, Garage Door Opener, Concrete Floors

Construction

Roofing: Asphalt
General: Frame, Wood Siding, Rough-Sawn, 1, Poured Concrete

Location

Road/Access: Gravel
HOA Amenities: Annually
Originating MLS: NGLRMLS API
School District: Lake City Area School District
County: Missaukee

Lot

Zoning: SEC 18 T24N R7W S 54 RDS OF E 29.6 RDS OF SW 1/4 OF SW 1/4. 9.99A.
View: Countryside View, View

Utilities

Water: Private
Sewer: Private Sewer

Financial

Source: NGLRMLS API
Ownership: Private Owner

Property

Year Built: 2022
Type: Single Family Home

Schools

District: Lake City Area School District

10/31/2025Active

10/31/2025$469,900@ 361 per ft²Listed

Listing Broker

Robin Stressman

1 @ Praedium Realty

License #: 6502409992

Email: robin@mtpleasant.net

Phone: 989-773-4387

Location: Mt. Pleasant, MI

Robin Stressman has been assisting buyers and sellers in Central Michigan since 1982, building lasting relationships along the way. Known for her dedication and personalized approach, she stays up to date with industry developments to ensure her clients’ interests are always well represented. Over the years, Robin’s professionalism and expertise have earned her numerous prestigious accolades and designations in real estate.

Last Updated: 12/02/2025 08:18:30 pm

Offered by: Sue Whipple, , 616-826-9737 @ City2Shore Real Estate Northern Michigan

MLS: #1940099

Source: Northern Great Lakes Realtors MLS

Copyright © 2025 Northern Great Lakes REALTORS® MLS™ All Rights Reserved. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The accuracy of all information, regardless of source, is not guaranteed or warranted. All information should be independently verified. Data displayed may be a portion of, and not a complete set of all listings published in the MLS.

View Listing

5800 W Moorestown Road, Lake City, MI 49651 is a 4 Bed, 2 Bath, 1,300 Sq Ft, 10.0 Acres, Single Family Home built in 2022.

This property is currently available and was listed by Northern Great Lakes Realtors MLS on 10/31/2025 04:06:42 am. The MLS # for the property is MLS #1940099.